Showing posts with label Gone with the Wind. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gone with the Wind. Show all posts

Friday, January 30, 2026

At the Midpoint: A Backward Glance at Best Pictures from 1927 to 1975.

A still from Wings (1927), the Academy's first Best Picture winner.
A scene from 1927's Wings, which won the award
for Outstanding Picture at the first Academy Awards.

With my review of One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest, I have now reviewed 49 Best Picture Winners (with an asterisk for Sunrise) out of a total of 98, putting me at the midpoint of this project. So this seems like a good moment to take a look back before moving forward.

One thing that this tour of (English language) film history has brought home to me is what a young medium motion pictures are. There are people who are alive now who had already been born when Wings and Sunrise were released. I'm only about halfway through, and this point will be a fair bit short of the midpoint by the time I fully catch up. Even so, I have already reached movies released within my lifetime, some of them ones that I wouldn't have considered "old" when I first viewed them.


EARLY FILM HISTORY AND PRE-HISTORY:

Film itself far predates the Academy Awards. Inventors experimented with creating moving images from mulitple static ones from the first half of the 19th century through devices such as the phenokistascope, later improved into the zoetrope. Thomas Edison (more accurately, his employee William Dickson)'s kinetoscope, invented in 1893, allowed exhibition of a film reel to a single viewer via a "peep box." But it was only with the creation of the Lumière Brothers' cinématographe in 1895 that mass exhibition became possible.

To all intents, motion pictures began with that invention, with the rest basically being prehistory. Now, 1895 is outside of living memory... but not by all that much, and it wasn't until after the turn of the 20th century that filmmakers started to deliver more complex narrative films, such as Edwin S. Porter's The Great Train Robbery and Georges Méliès's Le Voyage dans la Lune. The latter of which saw Thomas Edison become the first significant movie pirate by selling his own prints of Méliès's film under the English title, A Trip to the Moon, without permission, payment, or credit.

A robbery is one of the surviving scenes from 1906's The Story of the Kelly Gang.
The Kelly Gang performs a robbery in one of
the few surviving scenes from this 1906 feature.

The first recorded feature-length film was Australia's The Story of the Kelly Gang (1906), a 70 minute narrative film of which roughly 17 minutes still survive; a restoration was released by Australia's National Film and Sound Archive in 2006, combining the existing clips with still photos to recreate the original movie as closely as possible (National Film and Sound Archive of Australia, https://www.nfsa.gov.au/latest/story-kelly-gang).

It was D. W. Griffith's 1915 epic, The Birth of a Nation, that revolutionized film technique... sadly, in the service of what amounts to a 3-hour recruitment film for the Ku Klux Klan. I've already written about its content (link). The film was simultaneously a product of, and a fuel for, the period of history that historians have dubbed the nadir of American race relations.

Divorced of that content, however, The Birth of a Nation was a technical marvel. A lot of film language we take for granted can be traced to this motion picture: intercutting close-ups and long shots within a scene; fade-outs to show transitions in time and place; and large-scale battle scenes using a variety of methods to convey carnage, including the use of still frames to make living actors seem like lifeless corpses. Its content is odious - but its technical achievement is indisputable, and it fully merits its place in the Library of Congress's National Film Registry.

Eddie (Charles King) falls for Queenie (Anita Page) in The Broadway Melody.
The Broadway Melody is an "all-talking" film... meaning
the camera doesn't move and the actors barely do.

FROM SILENT TO SOUND:

All of this history is a prelude to the very first thing I noticed in this review series - namely, the way film technique actually moved backward with the introduction of sound.

Silent film was already on its way out by the time of the first Academy Awards ceremony. Wings and its twin "Best Unique and Artistic Motion Picture," Sunrise, would be the only silent films to win Best Picture until 2011's The Artist. The contrast in filmmaking sophistication between these two silent films and the early talkies that followed is jaw-dropping. Save for featuring synchronized sound, the Best Picture recipients from The Broadway Melody to Cavalcade seem far older and creakier than the two silent winners.

The reasons for this have to do with early sound recording technology, which Fiveable's article, Technological and Artistic Challenges of Early Talkies, observes was as cumbersome as it was expensive. Cameras had to be encased in soundproof booths to avoid recording the sound of the camera itself, which limited camera movement, while actors had to remain close to microphones to capture clear audio. The resulting films feel almost painfully primitive and static.

Filmmakers did their best to push against these limitations. The Broadway Melody cuts regularly between different camera setups to try to keep some sense of visual motion, and it pioneered the technique of dubbing singing over musical numbers rather than recording the songs live. Cimarron and All Quiet on the Western Front feature set pieces that were "shot silent," with sound later dubbed over, allowing individual sequences to draw on the wealth of tools that had been perfected before the introduction of sound. All Quiet was one of several early talkies that simultaneously shot a silent version. The silent version still exists, and it's often regarded as the better one, not having to contend with the limited camerawork and the sometimes stilted line deliveries.

I also couldn't help but notice how many early talkies feature elements of silent film, from exaggerated, overly emotive acting (Cimarron is very guilty of this) to intertitles. In hindsight, the run of Best Picture Winners up to 1934 plays like a transitional period, with filmmakers gradually learning how to best use the new sound technology, as well as how to minimize the limitations imposed by it.

The motion picture as an artform seems to regain its confidence in the mid-1930s. Frank Capra's It Happened One Night uses the advantages of synchronized sound to smoothly cut into action while it's in progress and cut out at high points, creating a faster pace than many of its contemporaries. The Great Ziegfeld, for all of its self-indulgence, features a then-extraordinary $250,000 set piece, a mid-film performance of A Pretty Girl Is Like a Melody on a giant revolving set, that remains eye-popping.

A Confederate flag flies over a sea of wounded men in 1939's Gone with the Wind.
1939's Gone with the Wind sees the movies finally catch
back up with the technical mastery of the silent era.

CATCHING UP WITH THE PAST - GONE WITH THE WIND:

1939's Gone with the Wind saw the motion picture industry finally "catching up" with the technical mastery of its silent era.

There is a certain irony to this. Silent film's revolutionary leap forward came with Birth of a Nation, a Civil War/Reconstruction epic that is deeply, blatantly racist. Sound film's revolutionary release that saw a full return to technical mastery came with Gone with the Wind, a Civil War/Reconstruction epic based on a novel by Margaret Mitchell - whose own favorite novel, The Clansman, formed the basis for Birth of a Nation.

It should be noted that, unlike its pro-KKK predecessor, Gone with the Wind avoided any deliberate racism on the insistence of David O. Selznick. The novel's references to the Klan were removed entirely from the movie, along with racial slurs. The film's most prominent black character, Mammy (Hattie McDaniel), is a fully-realized character who is arguably one of the best-written characters in the movie.

Gone with the Wind is a better movie than Birth of a Nation on a basic story and character level. It also offers several indelible moments: The shot that begins close on Scarlet; then, still moving to follow her, gradually pulls back to reveal a sea of wounded soldiers. The set piece that is the burning of Atlanta. The intimate and perfectly-edited moment in which Scarlet shoots a deserter, then rifles through his pockets for anything that can help her and her people survive.

As I noted in my review, for its first three hours, I was positive I would be awarding full marks. I ended up giving it an "8," mainly because its final hour suffered from a narrowing of scope and direction by Sam Wood that simply was not the equal of the scenes helmed by Victor Fleming or George Cukor. The movie as a whole, however, fully lives up to its reputation as a technical and artistic achievement, and it represents the point at which the visual art of motion pictures caught up with its own past and began to once again move forward.

1922's The Toll of the Sea shows off Technicolor's two-strip process.
1922's The Toll of the Sea was made using
Technicolor's early two-strip color process.

FROM BLACK & WHITE TO COLOR:

After silent-to-sound, the next major transition was from black & white to color. From 1927 to 1950, the only color movie to win Best Picture winner was Gone with the Wind.

Now, color was not remotely new, not even in the 1930s. Many early silent films had sequences that were colored by hand, frame-by-frame; some restorations replicate the process, including Wings with its colored flames during the aerial dogfights. Meanwhile, Technicolor utilized a two-strip color recording process, which was used for the entirety of 1922's The Toll of the Sea. This process was also used for individual sequences, big set pieces in movies such as the 1923 version of The Ten Commandments and the 1925 Ben-Hur.

The early Technicolor processes were cumbersome, though, as well as expensive. Also, like early sound, early color introduced limitations. The Artifice notes in its article, A History of Colour: The Difficult Transition from Black and White Cinematography, that cameras were so heavy that outdoor shooting was impossible. The article also notes the need for extremely bright lighting, limiting the use of shadows and restricting complex camera work.

Talkies imposed even greater restrictions, of course... but audiences quickly demanded talking films. The same audiences were perfectly satisfied with black & white, however, and so the expensive and cumbersome color process was saved for a few, lavish exceptions.

As the technology improved, color became more affordable, more effective, and less restrictive. The 1950s saw a steady increase in color motion pictures, and this was reflected in the Oscar winners. 1951's An American in Paris was only the second color movie to win Best Picture. After 1956's Around the World in 80 Days, however, 1960's The Apartment was the only black & white film to win the award until Schindler's List in 1993.

Jack Lemmon and Shirley MacLaine in The Apartment (1960).
The Apartment (1960) was the last black & white film
to win Best Picture until Schindler's List in 1993.

REFLECTING THE TIMES:

The one constant, throughout this series (and, really, any other decades-spanning look at artworks) is one that I've circled back to in multiple reviews and assorted musings: that the films in this series very much reflect the times in which they were made.

This is visibly true throughout the span of this review series. I've written about how portrayals of African-Americans on film reflected racial attitudes between 1915 and 1939; how views toward sexuality led to the fall of the Hays Code and the rise of the MPAA ratings; and how a turbulent social period overlaps a time in which the musical suddenly dominated the Academy Awards. The movies that are the most popular and/or honored often don't hold up as the actual best of their respective years - but movies, good and bad alike, always reflect something of the times that created them.


CONCLUSION:

I think it's appropriate that my look back comes here, not only because it's the current midpoint of this series, but also because the next Best Picture winner will be 1976's Rocky. If my memory holds true (and it hasn't been all that long since my last viewing), the first Rocky is very much a '70s film, but it also signals a shift in the overall tone of major motion pictures that would carry through into the following decade.

Past that, I have no particular conclusion here. I really did just want to blow off the cobwebs a bit by looking back at the first half of this review series before starting to move forward again.


Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Thursday, February 10, 2022

David O. Selznick vs. the Hays Office: Battling the censors for Gone with the Wind and Rebecca.

Rebecca (1940): Maxim de Winter (Laurence Olivier) has
a secret that's a lot less shocking than it should be...

"In the Tradition of Quality"
-company motto of Selznick International Pictures

For a brief moment, producer David O. Selznick's independent Selznick International Pictures was at the very top of the business. The studio had already released some successful and well-received films, several of which are now regarded as classics, including: A Star Is Born; The Prisoner of Zenda; and Intermezzo.

In 1939, Selznick released Gone with the Wind, which not only won the Best Picture Oscar but which remains - adjusted for inflation - the biggest ticket seller of all time. In 1940, his studio followed up with Rebecca, the only movie directed by Alfred Hitchcock to have won the Best Picture Oscar, and which was also a considerable box office success. Those two motion pictures made Selznick International 1940's top-grossing Hollywood film studio.

Both movies are marked by quality filmmaking and by screenplays that are remarkably faithful to their source novels. Both movies share another common feature: Selznick's struggles to guide them, intact, past the censors.

Gone with the Wind (1939): "Frankly, I just don't care." 
Doesn't quite have the same ring to it, does it?

GONE WITH THE WIND: THE HAYS OFFICE RETREATS

"No picture shall be produced which will lower the moral standards of those who see it. Hence the sympathy of the audience shall never be thrown to the side of crime, wrong-doing, evil or sin."
-the first of the major principles governing the Motion Picture Production Code, aka the Hays Code

The Motion Picture Production Code was not enforced through government entities. It was adopted in 1930 by the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) under the leadership of Will H. Hays, as a way for studios to police themselves - in no small part to prevent government censorship. There was no legal enforcement of the Code... but by 1934, mainstream American movie theaters would not screen a movie that lacked Hays Office approval.

David O. Selznick's published memos reflect his increasing frustration with these restrictions, particularly as they applied to Gone with the Wind and Rebecca. In the case of Gone with the Wind, most of the tension surrounded Clark Gable's final line: "Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn." The Hays Code strictly prohibited profanity, and the censorship office tried to persuade Selznick to change the line to "Frankly, I just don't care."

Selznick appealed the decision, ultimately lobbying Hays himself in an October 1939 memo.  He never actually threatened to release the film without Hays Office approval.  Still, it was clear that he was digging in hard in support of Rhett Butler's famous last words.

Selznick's lobbying worked. In November 1939, shortly before Gone with the Wind's official release, the Hays Office revised its code. A strict ban on any profanity was amended, so that profanity was allowed by censor discretion if it was deemed to be "essential and required."

In short: David O. Selznick battled the Hays Office, and he won. That time, at least...

Rebecca (1940): Mrs. Danvers caresses Mrs. de Winter's
cheek with the sleeve of the late Rebecca's dress.

REBECCA: SELZNICK FORCED TO COMPROMISE.

"There is one drastic change that was forced on us by the Hays Office and that almost caused us to abandon the picture. I don't want (author Daphne du Maurier) to think we are imbeciles when she sees this change... It was something forced upon us."
-David O. Selznick, preparing a message regarding changes to Rebecca.

Selznick's next motion picture also ran into problems with the Hays Office. Joseph Breen, head of Production Code Administration, wrote to Selznick that the screenplay for Rebecca violated the Code. In his report on the preproduction script, Breen observed that it contained "inescapable inferences of sex perversion" and references to a further "alleged illicit relationship," as well as including an ending that directly violated the Code's specifications.

Selznick's memos reveal his frustration, with him even contemplating something he'd never threatened with Gone with the Wind: To release the movie without Hays Office approval. But he was exactly one film too late for that. Gone with the Wind was not just a movie; it was an event. By November 1939, it was apparent that Gone with the Wind was going to succeed no matter what he Hays Office did, so the only sensible course for Hays was to find a way to endorse it - even if that meant changing the rules.

I actually prefer Rebecca as a movie... but it was not a cultural phenomenon like Gone with the Wind.  Not even close.  I suspect cooler heads were able to talk Selznick into compromising, even if it damaged the story.

It wasn't an outright loss for Selznick. The final film flatly ignores Breen's first two objections. Sinister housekeeper Mrs. Danvers (Judith Anderson)'s adoration of the deceased Rebecca has an all but unmistakable sexual element. In one of the movie's best scenes, Joan Fontaine's heroine walks into the bedroom previously occupied by Rebecca.  The room has been kept unchanged, maintained practically as a shrine. Mrs. Danvers proudly walks her new mistress through the room. She shows off Rebecca's luxurious dresses, fondling the sleeve of one before using that same sleeve to caress the new Mrs. de Winter's cheek. The young woman is both mesmerized and repelled. Mrs. Danvers then shows off Rebecca's nightgown, made of sheer fabric, pushing her hand beneath the gown and marveling at how she can see her hand through it - at which point the heroine visibly recoils and flees. It's subtext... but it's pretty strong subtext. Meanwhile, the scripted references to another "illicit relationship" that censor Breen objected to? They remain entirely intact.

While Selznick won two out of three battles on Rebecca, he did not win when it came to the ending. The backstory was significantly altered to gain Hays Code approval. Selznick was so disappointed by the decision that he prepared an explanation and apology to author Daphne du Maurier in the memo quoted above.

Tony Curtis and Jack Lemmon in Some Like It Hot: The movie that broke The Hays Code.


SOME LIKE IT HOT AND THE FALL OF THE HAYS CODE

"A film which followed the code of the Hays Office to the strictest letter might succeed in being a great work of art, but not in a world in which a Hays Office exists."
-Thedor W. Adorno

The Code was always doomed. The one constant in history is that the standards and values of the public change. After World War II and throughout the 1950s, more and more filmmakers came to Hollywood from abroad - filmmakers with little respect or patience for the Hays Code and who likely found personal satisfaction in pushing it as far as they could.  Meanwhile, European films offering blatant sexuality made American fare look plain and timid by comparison.

In 1959, Billy Wilder released his comedy classic, Some Like It Hot, starring Tony Curtis and Jack Lemmon as men who, after witnessing a gangland massacre, dress as women to evade the killers.  In the guise of a woman, Curtis falls for Marilyn Monroe, while Lemmon ends up engaged to another man. By today's standards, it plays like innocent fluff... But it played openly with ideas of fluid sexuality, and the Hays Office refused to endorse it.  The movie was further condemned by the Catholic League of Decency, which dubbed it "seriously offensive to Christian and traditional standards of morality and decency."

Neither Wilder nor studio United Artists were bothered in the least, and the lack of Hays Office approval did nothing to stop the film from being a huge critical and box office success. The Motion Picture Production Code would officially limp on until 1968 - but after Some Like It Hot, these guidelines, once upon a time enforced with absolute rigidity, were nothing but meaningless words on paper.

One suspects Selznick likely felt a tiny bit jealous that Wilder had done what he had once wanted to.

Review: Gone with the Wind
Review: Rebecca

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Wednesday, January 26, 2022

Gone with the Wind and Race: Musings about Controversies Surrounding "The Greatest Movie Ever Made."

One of the most stirring visuals from Gone with the Wind
 - dominated by a Confederate flag.

DISCLAIMER:

This posting is not a review of Gone with the Wind, but rather an overview of the controversies surrounding it, along with some historical context, and why I believe the movie still has value. My review of the film as a work of art and entertainment can be found here.


INTRODUCTION:

"Birth of a Nation was such a barefaced lie that a moron could see through it. Gone with the Wind is such a subtle lie that it will be swallowed as truth by millions of whites and blacks alike."
-Melvin B. Tolson

Gone with the Wind was released in 1939 to practically unanimous critical acclaim and an audience response that was no less than rapturous. Made on a then-incredible budget of almost $4 million, it made an even more incredible profit, racking up approximately $189 million in its first year of release. That's in 1939 money. When you factor in re-releases and adjust for inflation and changing ticket prices, its estimated total would be a staggering $3.4 billion. With that inflation adjustment, it remains the all-time box office champ. Star Wars? E. T.? Titanic? They don't even come close.

It is also a film surrounded by controversy, particularly over its depictions of slavery in the Old South. In 2020, the movie was temporarily removed from streaming service HBO Max; when it was restored, it was with a disclaimer about how the movie "denies the horrors of slavery."  It is far from the first time the movie has attracted this controversy, with intermittent protests dating back to its release. Malcolm X would later recall that when he first saw the movie, he was the only black person in the theater and that he felt "like crawling under the rug."

As my overall very positive review should make clear, I regard Gone with the Wind as a fine overall motion picture.  Performances are mostly excellent, many of the visual moments remain spellbinding, and for three of its four hours it actually lives up to its reputation as a masterpiece.  Its history of controversy doesn't exist for no reason, however; and while I thought HBO Max's much-mocked but short-lived removal of it was an overreaction, the film is part of a larger history that is well worth at least a brief overview.

Birth of a Nation (1915) - The first motion picture epic
is literally a Ku Klux Klan recruitment film.

EARLY AMERICAN CINEMA AND THE NADIR OF AMERICAN RACE RELATIONS:

"Every film is the result of the society that produced it."
-Jean-Luc Godard

As the above quote indicates, movies reflect the culture that makes them. Watch the movies made at a given time and you will learn a lot about how people thought and what they valued during that time.

Unfortunately, cinema was born during a period that has been dubbed "the nadir of American race relations." During this period, from roughly 1877 to 1923, post Civil War reconstruction ended in the South and the history of the Civil War was gradually re-written. By the end of the 19th century, a pro-Southern view of the conflict was predominant, and it would only grow more so for much of the 20th century.

It was also during this period, in 1915, that D. W. Griffith directed Birth of a Nation. Though it was not the first feature-length motion picture, it was the first large-scale epic... and at $100,000, it had a budget to match its ambitions. Griffith's film pioneered film techniques, from showing the carnage of a battlefield through use of still images, to hand-colored tinting of frames, to parallel editing that cut back and forth between scenes occurring simultaneously. It is impossible to overstate the importance of this movie's contribution to the motion picture arts; film critic Roger Ebert observed of it that "Griffith assembled and perfected the early discoveries of film language, and his cinematic techniques that have influenced the visual strategies of virtually every film made since."

It was also a massively racist film by any reasonable standard. It not only depicts the Civil War and Reconstruction from a pro-Confederacy point of view; its story actively celebrates the rise of the Ku Klux Klan. The climax of the film? The hero leads a heroic charge by KKK members to rescue his family, who are fending off a siege of their home by animalistically-depicted black men (played by whites in blackface, of course).

The movie not only reflected the prevailing views of the time; it amplified them. The heroic depiction of the Klan ignited recruitment in an organization that had previously gone dormant. It continued to be used as a KKK recruitment tool into the 1980s. It also was the first motion picture screened at the White House, where it received the approval of the U. S. President at that time: Woodrow Wilson, to whom the novel it was based on was dedicated.

A patriotic rally for the South in Gone with the Wind.

FROM BIRTH OF A NATION TO GONE WITH THE WIND:

"Our touchstones of slavery are Song of the South, Gone With the Wind and The Birth of a Nation. It's hard to separate the cinematic quality from the underlying themes. I appreciate the films, but the message was repugnant."
-John Ridley

The parallels between Birth of a Nation and Gone with the Wind are striking. Both are epic movies, far longer than the average motion picture. Birth of a Nation ran more than three hours at at a time when it was rare for a movie to exceed 60 minutes; Gone with the Wind unfolds across almost four hours. Both center around the Civil War and Reconstruction, both are told from a pro-Southern point-of-view, and both celebrate the Old South as an almost mythical land of gallantry - Gone with the Wind even more than Birth of a Nation.

Gone with the Wind was not made during the "nadir," and producer David Selznick actively insisted on adapting the novel to make its non-white characters come out "decidedly on the right side of the ledger." He insisted on the removal of the novel's references to the Ku Klux Klan, along with all usages of the "N" word. A scene from the book in which Scarlett is attacked by a runaway slave was altered to make the primary assailant a white man. Selznick was adamant that he would not make "an anti-Negro picture."

His efforts made the film seem unobjectionable to white audiences at the time, but they also downplayed the idea of racial conflict even existing in the Old South. Essentially, it's the same offense that would plague Disney's Song of the South. In both films, the effort to avoid active offense created an alternate reality, one in which blacks were happy in servitude, as if such was the natural order of things.

Hattie McDaniel's Mammy: Almost certainly the smartest
character in the film... and a fully-realized human being.

IN DEFENSE OF A PROBLEMATIC CLASSIC:

"I'd rather make $700 a week playing a maid than earn $7 a day being a maid."
-Hattie McDaniel

All of the above is meant to describe and give context to the controversy that has grown around Gone with the Wind. Please do not mistake it as any kind of support of censorship of a classic motion picture. I don't object to disclaimers, as long as the film itself remains intact... and to be clear, in Gone with the Wind's case, it's not only intact; it probably looks and sounds better than it did on release. I agree that the film is problematic, and that the filmmakers' efforts to "fix" this ended up creating new and different problems. Nevertheless, having acknowledged all this, I will now proceed to defend it anyway.

Gone with the Wind celebrates the mythology of the Noble Lost Cause of the Confederacy, complete with an opening crawl decrying the loss of "a land of Cavaliers and Cotton Fields... the last ever to be seen of Knights and their Ladies Fair, of Master and Slave..." This can be uncomfortable viewing, particularly from a modern standpoint. However, the championing of that mythology in a movie so spectacularly popular tells us more about the prevailing views of 1939 than a million scholarly essays could hope to do.  Even if the movie was bad or ill-intentioned (which it isn't), that insight into the popular mindset of 1939 would be valuable in itself.

Nor is the film as one-dimensional in its views as The Birth of a Nation was. Just before the announcement of war, a significant scene shows Rhett Butler pointing out how tactically hopeless the South's position is and dismissing the rallying cries of the other Southerners as "arrogance." He is proved right on every count. Scarlett later decries the boasting of the Southern men, blaming her situation on those men's eagerness for conflict. The story's sympathies may lie with the South... but while it may turn a blind eye to issues of race, it's not blind to all of the South's blind spots.

It should also be pointed out that, at the time this was made, very few major movies featured significant roles for black actors. Of the previous Best Picture winners, the only truly substantial African American role was Cimarron's Isaiah (Eugene Jackson), the child servant who stowed away with the central couple when they settled in Oklahoma. Isaiah was a poor character, stereotypical and dimwitted. He represented an improvement over the portrayal of blacks in The Birth of a Nation only in that he was actually played an African American child actor, and that he was at least meant to be seen sympathetically.  In all other respects, he was portrayed as less than a full human being.

Isaiah (Eugene Jackson) in Cimarron: Less than fully human.

Gone with the Wind was released a mere eight years later, and yet its black characters are substantially more three-dimensional. While the word "Mammy" has since taken on the connotation of a racial stereotype, the actual character played by Hattie McDaniel is arguably the smartest character in the movie. She recognizes both Scarlett and Rhett for who they are, and she recognizes the full reality of the characters' changing situation at every point in the story. She is also a fully realized human being: sometimes funny, sometimes compassionate, other times grumbling or taking people to task even as she does what's necessary to help.  McDaniel's performance remains outstanding, and she justifiably won a Supporting Actress Oscar for it - the first African American performer to win an Academy Award (though at the ceremony, she was consigned to segregated seating).

Finally, the sheer craft that went into the making of this movie cannot be dismissed. Ebert's words about Birth of a Nation also extend to Gone with the Wind. This film may not have invented the techniques it utilized - but it certainly perfected them, and with a result that while problematic, is far less directly offensive than the earlier film had been.

Gone with the Wind's Tara: A gorgeous view
of a romantic past that never actually existed.

OVERALL:

"Is Gone with the Wind objectionable? Certainly. Is it some kind of masterpiece of Hollywood storytelling? Yes."
-John Beifuss

Films are cultural artifacts. This lends value to even the most mediocre throwaway, because even that gives insight into the prevailing values of the times. The alien invasion films so popular in the 1950s reflect paranoia about Communism and foreign influence; the conspiracy thrillers of the 1970s showcase mistrust of authority in the wake of the Watergate Scandal and the Vietnam War; the jingoistic action flicks of the 1980s mirror the right-wing attitudes that dominated the US and the UK during that decade, while the borderline (and in some cases, openly) misogynistic sex comedies of the same decade tell us something about 1980s sexual politics.

If there is value even in junk, then it stands to reason that there's more value in looking at art. Certainly, we can acknowledge the ways in which Gone with the Wind promotes views that no longer align with ours. But doing so should not preclude acknowledging its status as a finely-crafted, often spellbinding motion picture. You don't have to be blind to its failings to enjoy it for its fine performances, for its exquisite music score, for its stunning production values, and even - and perhaps, especially - for its overblown melodrama.

In conclusion: In my review, I stated that I felt the final hour of Gone with the Wind was misjudged and drawn out, breaking the spell cast by the previous three hours.  Similarly, I agree that this story presents a distorted view of history and, largely unconsciously, advances views that are at odds with many of today's prevailing views.  Just as the artistic failings of the film's final stretch don't stop it from being a film worth watching, neither do its sociological issues.  It remains an important film, of value as a historical and cultural artifact - and also as an accomplished work of art in its own right.

Review: Gone with the Wind

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

1939: Gone with the Wind.

Scarlett O'Hara and her father look over their home, Tara.

Release Date: Dec. 15, 1939. Running Time: 233 minutes. Screenplay: Sidney Howard. Based on the novel by: Margaret Mitchell. Producer: David O. Selznick. Director: Victor Fleming; George Cukor (uncredited); Sam Wood (uncredited).


DISCLAIMER:

In recent years, Gone with the Wind has been subject to a (not entirely new) backlash for its problematic racial politics. Rather than either ignore this or try to squeeze a 1 - 2 paragraph section about it into an otherwise unrelated discussion of the movie's artistic merits, I will instead cover its controversies in a separate posting.

My overview of Gone with the Wind as a cultural artifact can be found here. The rest of this review will evaluate it strictly as a movie, one whose historical significance and artistic accomplishment is undeniable - but also one that has some dramatic flaws that I think have sometimes gone unacknowledged.


THE PLOT:

Scarlett O'Hara (Vivien Leigh) has lived a life of privilege as a Southern belle on her family's plantation, Tara. She is mostly oblivious to chatter about war with the North, and is far more concerned that her longtime crush, Ashley Wilkes (Leslie Howard), has become engaged to sweet and lovely Melanie Hamilton (Olivia de Havilland).

At their engagement party, Scarlett meets Rhett Butler (Clark Gable), a disreputable Virginian who scorns the war fervor. When war comes, the upheaval will see Scarlett's life transformed. As she struggles through poverty and deprivation, she makes a vow - one that she will keep no matter what she must do or who she must hurt:

"As God is my witness, I will never be hungry again!"

Not a gentleman: Rhett Butler (Clark Gable)
leers at Scarlett from the bottom of a staircase.

CLARK GABLE AS RHETT BUTLER:

Clark Gable was at the height of his stardom, and he receives a star's introduction: a shot that zooms in on him as he watches (well, leers at) Scarlett from the bottom of a staircase. The moment more or less establishes their relationship. His interest is obvious, but he is not about to join the boys buzzing aroud her like bees around their queen. Her interest is equally apparent, particularly when she learns of his scandalous reputation, but she feigns indifference. At the end of the movie, he blames her for never meeting him halfway, but he's just as guilty; he won't ascend toward her, she won't descend toward him, and all their conflict and arguments amount to attempts by each to establish dominance over the other.

If Rhett's first scene encapsulates his relationship with Scarlett, then his second reveals his clear-eyed, if slightly self-conscious, cynicism. The other men at the party are swept away by war fervor, and Rhett takes pleasure in making himself the object of scorn when he bluntly assesses the South's chances: "The Yankees are better equipped than we. They've got factories, shipyards, coal mines, and a fleet to bottle up our harbors and starve us to death. All we've got is cotton, and slaves, and arrogance." When he refuses to be baited into a duel by young Charles Hamilton (Rand Brooks), Hamilton implies that he's a coward - until Ashley Wilkes points out that Butler is "one of the best shots in the country," and that his refusal to fight is actually a kindness.

Scarlett O'Hara (Vivien Leigh) plays the seductress.

VIVIEN LEIGH AS SCARLETT O'HARA:

Gable is the star, and he is very much treated as such. But he's also offscreen for much of the movie - and when the last hour of the film makes him the central figure, it results in the movie's weakest extended passage.

That's because Gone with the Wind isn't Rhett's story, but Scarlett's. At the time her casting was announced, Vivien Leigh met with public resistance - How dare a Brit be cast in such an inherently American role? Then the film came out, and that resistance died. It's impossible to imagine the film with a different actress. Leigh is fearless in conveying all of Scarlett's unlikable traits: She's selfish, manipulative, and more than a little narcissistic. But she also brings the underlying strength the character demands.

For all of her faults, Scarlett never crosses the line into seeming unredeemable. There's a disconnect between her vindictive words and her actions. The forty minutes of film leading up to the intermission are notable. Scarlett first declares that she hates Melanie and her unborn baby for keeping her in Atlanta when she really wants to return home. But when Melanie goes into labor, Scarlett delivers the baby. Her efforts keep Melanie and the baby alive long enough for Rhett to get them out of the burning city; and after Rhett leaves them to join the war effort, Scarlett takes charge, making sure they all survive not only to reach Tara, but through the months of poverty that follow. It's a flat-out heroic effort that far eclipses the demands of the promise she made to Melanie's husband.

Hattie McDaniel as Mammy, almost
certainly the smartest character in the film.

OTHER CHARACTERS:

Ashley Wilkes: Leslie Howard does not give one of his better performances as the long-time object of Scarlett's affections, and it is unfortunate that this is many viewers' sole exposure to him. Howard is too old, and he seems far too aware of this, resulting in a performance that's uncomfortable and mannered. Even more than age, I suspect, he had just reached his breaking point with playing weaklings and cowards. "I hate the damn part," he wrote to his daughter; and after it was done, the rest of his too-brief career would be spent playing stronger characters in movies aimed at supporting the British war effort.

Melanie Hamilton: Olivia de Havilland does the impossible, bringing humanity to a character who could so easily have come across as a sanctimonious saint. She does this by making sure that Melanie never comes across as a fool. Whatever she may say, her nonverbal reactions show that she is fully aware of Scarlett's faults, including her flirtation with her husband - She just isn't willing to reduce her to those faults. Both de Havilland and the script find moments of steel that prove the lie in Ashley's claim that she lacks Scarlett's strength. After Scarlett is attacked by vagrants, Ashley leads a posse to clear out the spot where she was attacked - something that could easily lead to him being hanged by the occupying Union forces. Melanie takes charge throughout the scene, keeping Scarlett quiet while silencing the other women's recriminations, and behaving with poise when a Union officer comes to search the house.

Mammy: Hattie McDaniel became the first African American actor to receive an Oscar, awarded Best Supporting Actress, and the award was well deserved. This part could easily have come across as a condescending comedy stereotype, but McDaniel plays her with intelligence and strength. She's effectively the movie's Greek chorus, as she observes the misadventures of Scarlett and Rhett, clear-eyed about their faults as individuals and as a couple even as she supports them. Despite the superficial subservience of her role, she never comes across as weak, and is always presented as a full human being: funny in some scenes, compassionate in others, grumbling complaints to her charges even as she goes beyond the demands of simple duty to help them. At one point, Rhett names her as the only person whose respect he actually craves.

Casualties of war: the dead and dying during the siege of Atlanta.

THREE DIRECTORS AND THEIR MICROMANAGER PRODUCER:

Though director George Cukor was attached through more than two years of preproduction, playing a major role in shaping the film, he ran into problems with both Selznick and Clark Gable: He clashed with Selznick over both the script and Selznick's interference, while Gable reportedly resented being directed by "a fairy." Cukor might have weathered one conflict or the other, but not both, and he was fired a little more than two weeks into filming. Though much of Cukor's footage ended up being reshot, Selznick later estimated that "a solid three reels" of Cukor's scenes remain in the movie, including such well-remembered moments as Melanie's childbirth and the shooting of a deserter; and Vivien Leigh and Olivia de Havilland continued to seek his guidance on their performances throughout the remainder of production.

Wizard of Oz director Victor Fleming was Gable's personal preference, and he shot the majority of the movie before leaving due to exhaustion. Sam Wood took over for a brief period, and Selznick's published memos indicate that some consideration was given to keeping him on... but in the end, Wood's footage wasn't at the level of either Cukor's or Fleming's. Fortunately, Fleming was able to recover to finish the film, and ended up with the sole director's credit.

Given all this, it's remarkable how visually and tonally consistent the final product is. Though Cukor particularly chafed at Selznick's micromanaging, that very quality probably saved the movie. Cukor oversaw the planning; Fleming shot most of it; Wood kept the production alive. Where I'm aware of a director/scene match (and I'm mostly not), I'd judge Cukor's footage to have more emotional intensity and Fleming's to have more visual sweep... but regardless of who shot what, the end film was Selznick's, and the very dictatorial control that made the production so hard on cast and crew is almost certainly what kept the end result unified.

Rhett declares his love for Scarlett.

THOUGHTS:

There are two solid hours of Gone with the Wind that are every bit the equal of the movie's reputation. The second and third hours are spellbinding. Scarlett is taken from privilege to poverty, and back to wealth that is this time wrested from the world through the force of her own will. This journey is reflected by her character arc. She begins as a Southern belle whose world seems to exist to accommodate her every whim. When Atlanta starts literally burning around her, she insists on returning home, fleeing to the safety of family and childhood... But home is a broken place, and she is forced to rely on her own ingenuity first to survive and eventually to thrive.

The cinematic technique on display is breathtaking, with individual shots that the mind can't help but hold onto. Wounded and dying men spread out across an Atlanta square. Rhett and Scarlett escape from Atlanta, fending off the desperate and the dangerous as the city burns around them. Rhett professes his love for Scarlett against a sky of pure red. Scarlett, alone with a Union deserter, plants herself against a wall as he approaches, concealing the gun she is holding until the second she resolves to defend herself.  Then she and Melanie eagerly rifle through the dead man's pockets for money to allow them to survive for just a little while longer... all of this supported by one of the most instantly recognizable music scores this side of Jaws or Star Wars.

Unfortunately, the movie's grip falters during its final hour. The focus narrows, the backdrop of Reconstruction vanishing as the drama becomes solely concerned with Rhett and Scarlett's relationship. Minus the broader context, with suddenly no more scenes centered around Scarlett's business efforts or complications caused by Union troops, the toxic antics of Rhett and Scarlett are reduced to the stuff of soap opera. The movie also suddenly looks cheaper, I suspect a result of the action moving mostly away from locations and into indoor studio sets.

Probably the most misjudged element about this final hour is a switch in protagonist. For three solid hours, we have followed Scarlett's story and journey. Suddenly, however, Rhett becomes the viewpoint character, with Scarlett absent from several scenes. The movie essentially changes its orbit, and the whole atmosphere is thrown off-kilter. Also, while Gable's Rhett charms and dominates as a supporting character when seen through other people's eyes, up close it becomes rapidly apparent that there's nothing particularly remarkable or even interesting about him.

The movie does recover for the ending, returning to Scarlett's viewpoint for its final scenes. And yes, "Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn" is a wonderful line, well delivered in the midst of a beautifully photographed exit. But for me, at least, it comes too late to recapture the magic of the film's first three hours.


SEQUELS AND RETELLINGS:

Various sequels and alternate versions of Gone with the Wind have been published in print form. Three were authorized by Margaret Mitchell's estate: Alexandra Ripley's 1991 novel, Scarlett; and Donald McCraig's novels, Rhett Butler's People in 2007 and Ruth's Journey in 2014. Others were unauthorized, but managed to make it into print, one (The Wind Done Gone) after substantial legal wrangling; and one (The Winds of Tara) only in Australia, where the Gone with the Wind copyright had expired.

The only of these to have been filmed was Scarlett, made into a television miniseries in 1994. Starring Joanne Whalley-Kilmer as Scarlett O'Hara and Timothy Dalton as Rhett Butler, this follow-up avoids having to deal with the uncomfortable history of the post-Reconstruction South by moving the action to Ireland, where she becomes involved with an unscrupulous aristocrat (Sean Bean). I have neither read the book nor seen the mini-series, and I have no interest in doing so. Reception was mixed at the time for both book and movie, and their reputation has if anything decreased in the decades since.

Scarlett and Melanie (Olivia de Havilland) read a casualty list.

OVERALL:

For its first three hours, I would have said that Gone with the Wind stands as a masterpiece in spite of its problematic racial politics. The first hour is a bit slow, but that's often the case with large-scale movies; it takes time to establish characters and set the major events in motion. Once that groundwork has been laid, the next two hours are among the finest 120 minutes of film I have seen. At the 3 hour mark, I was certain I would be awarding a perfect "10."

The spell breaks in the final hour. The focus narrows to unremarkable domestic drama, and the script makes an ill-advised switch in viewpoint that is to the detriment of both leads. It finds its focus again in the final scenes, but by then the damage has been done.

It remains a fine movie, with some outstanding performances and some superb cinematic craftsmanship. But the stumbles of the final hour leave me deducting a couple points from the final score.


Overall Rating: 8/10.

Related Post: Gone with the Wind and Race: Musings about the Controversies Surrounding "The Greatest Movie Ever Made."

Related Post: David O. Selznick vs. the Hays Office: Battling the Censors for Gone with the Wind and Rebecca

Outstanding Production - 1938: You Can't Take It With You
Outstanding Production - 1940: Rebecca

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads: